Remember if you decide mid-wife, it will be a much more personal experience. She will be with you thru it all, take care of you & baby… With a mid-wife as many family members as you feel comfy with will be allowed by your side. You might think that is crazy to have more than hubby or mom. But so many people are waiting for that little one and you will be at a place where it just doesn’t matter. My hubby, mom, step-dad, sister & step-mom were all there. Heck, the president could have come and I wouldn’t have cared as long as he helped hold my legs up… lol You’ll understand what I mean later if your labor is long. She made them all feel like she was part of our family. They were all very impressed with her Plus with a mid-wife I was placed in a room at the hospital much like my own bedroom, wallhangings, reclining chairs for the family, wallpaper, tv… it really was a ‘homey & comfy’ atmosphere. Plus I had a hot tub With doc… You are carted to the delivery room….

Its up to you sweetie… And what will make you most comfy. I was the ONLY person I know that went mid-wife and that didn’t stop me any Good luck and congrats!!
References :

My sister-in-law used a midwife, and she loved her, though there were some concerns about my little niece in utero and post-delivery (but she was born in a hospital, and everything checked out and she is now happy and healthy). My sister-in-law also never thought of switching.

So, as you can see, it’s not so much the title as it is the person who is delivering your baby. I would not recommend writing someone off because they were a doctor and not a midwife or vice versa. If you are interested in a midwife, by all means check it out. If that doesn’t work out, you could switch to a doctor. The goal is a healthy baby at the end of the line!
References :

Many certified nurse midwives work out of clinics that are associated with physicians, so that if your pregnancy is anything other than normal, you have a team of both midwives and physicians, which is ideal.

Midwives often spend most of your labor with you in the room, providing support, encouragement, etc. all through labor and they do deliver the baby as well. Doctors essentially show up to "catch" the baby.

Midwives can do everything a physician can except perform c-sections. You can have pain relief with a midwife too – some people believe you can’t if you have a midwife.

Doulas are also good support. They are trained in laboring women and relaxation techniques, positions that are helpful, etc. but they are not medically trained so therefore you need a midwife or a doctor to actually monitor the baby and do the delivery.
References :
RN, mom of 3, 2 delivered by physicians and 1 by a midwife.